Key Lime Pie Mocktail (Refined Sugar Free, Dairy Free)

Name: Key Lime Pie Mocktail
Prep time: 5 min
Total time: 5 min
Ingredients: 1/2 cup pineapple juice (Make sure it is pure pineapple juice with no sugar added!); 1/4 cup coconut milk (Can use almond milk.); 3 whole limes (Rolled, and juiced. ); lime slices; coconut whipped cream; gluten free graham crackers (sprinkled )

jump to recipe / print recipe

This Key Lime Pie Mocktail is exactly what you need on a warm summer day! This baby is naturally dairy free and oh so delicious. It tastes just like the real thing, key lime pie. On top of that, it is super simple to make, requiring only 5 minutes of hands on time.

key lime pie mocktail in a cocktail glass with flowers

If you have been following along for a while you know how obsessed I am with mocktails. I took a poll on instagram the other asking what kind of recipes you guys wanted to see this spring and summer and this was one of them! This may be my new favorite. Be sure to check out all of my other favorite mocktails on my website like my Watermelon Mocktail, Fig Simple Syrup, Peach Mocktails, and Grapefruit Mocktails! It is one of my favorites.

Jump to:

Why This Recipe Works
Ingredients
Substitutions And Variations
Step By Step Instructions
Fun Citrus Treats To Pair With
Equipment Needed
Expert Tips
Recipe FAQs
Storage Instructions
Other Fun Mocktails You Will Love
Key Lime Pie Mocktail

Why This Recipe Works

This recipe only takes 5 minutes to make!
My homemade mocktail tastes just like key lime pie, although it is much lighter and actually refreshing.
This recipe is naturally dairy free, gluten free, soy free, egg free, paleo, refined sugar free and vegan.
You can prep this drink in advance so you can have it all ready to go for dinner!
If you are a big pie fan, like me, and want to enjoy this mocktail with a slice of actual pie, you have to check out my Homemade Grain Free Pie Crust. It is so simple to make!

Ingredients

Coconut milk-This is what gives the drink the creamy pie like flavor. I like the coconut milk because it is nice and light.
Limes-The limes are what makes this drink! I always prefer fresh juice over store bought. If you do buy store bought, make sure there are not any added sugars.
Pineapple juice-This is what sweetens this drink. You can obviously make your own with a juicer, or you can buy organic pineapple juice. Just make sure nothing funky is added to it.

See the recipe card below for a full list of ingredients and measurements.

Substitutions And Variations

Coconut sugar-for the rim. You can also also use brown sugar if you are not avoiding refined sugars.
Coconut whipped cream– to garnish and drizzle on top.
Dairy free graham crackers– to sprinkle.
Fresh flowers- to garnish.
Coconut milk-If you are not dairy free, you can use heavy cream.

This recipe has not been tested with any other substitutions or variations. If you try something else out please let me know how it turns out in the comments below!

Step By Step Instructions

Coconut milk, pineapple juice and lime juice in a cocktail mixer with a large cocktail spoon. — Step #1: Place the coconut milk, pineapple juice and lime juice in the cocktail mixer and mix with a spoon until well mixed throughout.

Cocktail glass rim dipped in graham crackers. — Step #2: Wet the rim of your cocktail glass with water and drip the rim in graham crackers and or coconut sugar. Then pour the mocktail in the glass and add ice cubes if desired.

Fun Citrus Treats To Pair With

Equipment Needed

A large cocktail mixer- While this is not a must, it makes it easier to mix the mocktail!
Citrus juicer-If you are using fresh limes this will make it so much easier to juice them!

Expert Tips

Tip #1: Make sure your limes are ripe! The best way to tell if your limes are ripe is by the texture. They should be somewhat soft. If you leave limes sit out on your counter it will help them ripen faster.
Tip #2: The sugar rim is what makes this drink! Do not skip this step.

Recipe FAQs

Can I make this recipe in advance?

Yes! However, be sure to wait to mix it with ice and add the garnish until you are ready to drink it.

What kind of pineapple juicer should I use?

I love pure pineapple juice that comes in a can. Make sure whatever kind you buy is free of any additives.

When should I make this drink?

This drink is perfect for bridal showers, baby showers or just a girls tea part and brunch!

Key lime mocktail in a fun cocktail glass with a lime on the rim.

Storage Instructions

This recipe can last in the fridge for up to 5 days.
Be sure to store this drink in an air tight container to preserve it’s freshness!

Other Fun Mocktails You Will Love

if you are into healthy eating, be sure to download my FREE healthy swap guide

download your free guide